Transitioning to an ETF Retirement Portfolio

Growth Portfolios built with ETFs look a bit different from income-oriented Retirement Portfolios. Since we invest keeping growth in mind throughout our working lives, as intended in the Growth Portfolio's design, how do we make the transition to a Retirement Portfolio?

You want to think about this transition well ahead of time to be tax smart and prepare yourself financially and emotionally for retirement.

To avoid getting whacked with taxes, you should avoid selling any investments in your Cash/Margin accounts. Try to fund your desired portfolio with new savings and existing dividend/distribution income.

Target Savings Towards the Portfolio You Want

The first step is to assess your own assets currently and pick the Retirement Portfolio that you want to go with. Don't forget that your assets do not just include your portfolio. You should also consider your home, small business, shares in other businesses, or any other investments you may have. Many people sell some (or all) of these assets in retirement and they are often sold with tax advantages built in.

If you plan to significantly downsize your home and sell your small business, you might find yourself paying little to no taxes on these transactions. The realized value might be enough to fund the required components of your target Retirement Portfolio.

Generally, when shifting your portfolio, you will need to buy 10% each of short term bonds and preferred shares. You may also need to buy corporate bonds and REITs. This can add up to 40% of your total, and still growing portfolio, which is a substantial amount of money.

If you're not going to free up assets in other areas, you will have to fund these components from your current savings as you approach retirement. Also use your distribution income from current investments. Depending on your savings rate, you will need 5 to 10 years of saving before retirement to purchase to these missing components.

First Steps to Take

I would start with the Cash Cushion, which typically should be held in your Cash/Margin Account. (Remember to open two joint Cash/Margin accounts if needed for tax efficiency.)

Direct all savings to short-term bonds until the Cash Cushion is worth 10% of your total portfolio value. The cushion will come in handy in any bad situation as you approach retirement and the interest income is quite low so it won't substantially impact your tax bill.

After the Cash Cushion is built up, you should take a step back and look at your entire account picture. You want to make sure you are tax-optimized for retirement as tax savings will reduce your drawdowns and increase your success rate.

Account Type Considerations

You will have a TFSA, probably RRSPs as well, and a non-registered (Cash/Margin) investment account. In retirement you want to make sure Canadian dividend income will be realized in your Cash/Margin accounts and interest income in your RRSPs.

Remember you can shift your ETFs within registered accounts without affecting your taxes. Just don't make any account withdrawals!

The next step is building your preferred share allocation. Preferred shares should be held in your Cash/Margin accounts as they generate tax-friendly Canadian dividend income.

After this, it is likely you will need to start selling some assets within your TFSA & RRSP accounts. For example, if your Canadian stock ETF is in your RRSP, sell a chunk of it within the account each year. Use your new savings to buy Canadian dividend ETFs in your Cash/Margin accounts. Within the RRSP, buy your 10% corporate bond allocation instead as it generates interest income.

I believe the best place for REIT allocations is in your TFSA accounts. REIT income is a mixed bag of income types which are all taxed differently and come in different proportions from year to year. Approaching retirement, use your new TFSA contributions to buy your desired REIT allocation.

Final Touches

When retiring, you should make your final account shifts to achieve your final desired allocation and make sure the right ETFs are in the right places for tax efficiency.

This means you will be doing some buying and selling within your registered accounts. Use my tax guide to get an idea of proper allocations.

  • All bonds (except the Cash Cushion) should be in RRSP accounts.
  • Canadian dividend paying ETFs should be in Cash/Margin, or TFSA if you don't have a Cash/Margin account.
  • Foreign stock ETFs can be in your TFSA or RRSP first. If you need to have them in Cash/Margin accounts consider swap-based ETFs.
  • If you have a larger RRSP filled with U.S. corporate bonds and your U.S. stock allocation, be smart and switch to a U.S. dollar RRSP and hold comparable U.S.-listed ETFs to save on withholding taxes.

Summary

Planning ahead and giving yourself plenty of time to make the right moves will make things a lot easier in retirement. For an average couple in retirement with full TFSAs, healthy RRSPs, and Cash/Margin accounts generating Canadian dividend income, your income taxes should be super low (around 10%).

Investment assets of $1 million generating $40,000 a year split between two people, plus CPP/OAS income, should add up to a total tax bill of less than $5,000 in BC, AB, SK, or ON. That's less than a 10% tax rate when averaged over all income. It can be even $0 with certain account setups.

OAS is really a form of negative tax as it's a government benefit which you don't directly contribute to. Although it's a taxable benefit, often your after-tax OAS income will exceed the taxes on your CPP and investment income. What a fantastic country to grow old in!

If you own a small business, work with your CPA and a good financial adviser to plan your shift to retirement allocations well in advance. Proper planning can save you tens of thousands in taxes.

Comments & Questions

All comments are moderated before being posted for public viewing. Please don't send in multiple comments if yours doesn't appear right away. It can take up to 24 hours before comments are posted.

Comments containing links or "trolling" will not be posted. Comments with profane language or those which reveal personal information will be edited by moderator.

Leave a Reply